Is Amazon’s Price Checking App A Threat To Small Businesses?

Amazon raised hackles of small business owners across the country when it encouraged shoppers to download its new price-checking app and to head out to local stores to scan prices from Friday to Saturday night (Dec. 9 – 10).

“Of course, stores have long encouraged shoppers to snoop on competitors, and rewarded them for doing so. Amazon has just found an extraordinarily efficient way, one befitting its behemoth status, to do it,” Robb Mandelbaum wrote in The New York Times.

Garden retailer Donna Kutil had an even stronger reaction. “Get ready for a new level of evil,” she wrote on Today’s Garden Center’s Fresh Air Forum. After explaining last weekend’s planned promotion, she stakes out exactly why she is worried: “Not only will this hurt small businesses that can’t compete with big box prices, but it will also add to Amazon’s growing level of intelligence on what their customers want to buy.”

For its part, an Amazon spokesperson told the New York Times Mandelbaum that the new app is not really designed for small local stores. Rather, she said it is “primarily intended for customers who are comparing prices in major retail chain stores.”

We asked business consultant Laurie Brown, author of “The Greet Your Customer Manual,” to weigh in on the issue.

TGC: What exactly worries you about the new app?

BROWN: I worry that with the use of this app that all purchase decisions will come down to lowest price. Consumers, with money being tight, do want to make smart buying decisions. But a smart decision is not only based on money. Let’s take a garden center, for example. Perhaps I can buy my plant food on Amazon and save a couple of dollars. Fine and dandy. But, how can I take a leaf that has some burning or bugs and show it to the folks at Amazon and have them analyze and prescribe a solution? You can’t.

So, my concern is that if people only choose lower price, they will, in essence, kill off the place they go to when they need help.

TGC: How widely do you believe the new app will be used?

BROWN: I truly don’t know how widely it will be used. I think with money being tight consumers feel that they need to seek the lowest price.

TGC: What do you think the long term affect will be?

BROWN: My worst fear is that small garden centers will go under.

How can they combat that? Education.

I think that small businesses need to fight back and let consumers know what they get when they purchase from them. (i.e., local hires, knowledgeable staff, personalized attention, knowledge of the community, etc.) I guess a business might want to offer a price match to anything found on Amazon… but I think that is the wrong way to go.

Topics:

Leave a Reply

2 comments on “Is Amazon’s Price Checking App A Threat To Small Businesses?

  1. Let me start by saying “Quality will be remembered long after the price has been paid”

    There is a simple way to combat this approach.

    First provide superior customer service
    Second, bundle your products so that it’s impossible to compare, just like the big boxes sell the same product with a different SKU number from the manufacturer.
    Third you could try our really helpful ‘Weekend Garden Kit’ that is totally flexible and only available at Independent Retailers.

  2. There are a lot of really plant-bug smart garden centers suffering greatly because they haven’t figured out how to translate information into rings of the register. I think a reliance on providing information as a competitive strategy has caused many garden centers to ignore some other essential business factors. These include selling enough stuff at price margins that work, creating added value with their place and service, and keeping expenses (especially wage costs) in line with the value they create.

More From Departments...
Garden Design Magazine

August 28, 2015

Garden Design Magazine Now Available For Sale At Independent Garden Centers

The upscale magazine, which was previously available only through the publisher’s website, focuses on high-end outdoor design and lifestyle trends.

Read More
Steve Bailey

August 27, 2015

How To Set An Attained Margin Percentage Goal At Your Store [Talkin’ Finance With Steve Bailey]

One retailer asked this question: Is there an attained margin percentage that is considered a good goal for garden centers and their various product lines? Check out financial consultant Steve Bailey's advice.

Read More
Viola ‘Sorbet XP Coconut Swirl’ (PanAmerican Seed)

August 26, 2015

19 Versatile Cool-Weather Annuals For Beds, Borders And Containers [Slideshow]

Annuals can be versatile not just in their suitability for cool conditions, but in their adaptable use in beds, borders and containers. Here are breeders' recommendations on their top new selections.

Read More
Latest Stories
Garden Design Magazine

August 28, 2015

Garden Design Magazine Now Available For Sale At Indepe…

The upscale magazine, which was previously available only through the publisher’s website, focuses on high-end outdoor design and lifestyle trends.

Read More
Steve Bailey

August 27, 2015

How To Set An Attained Margin Percentage Goal At Your S…

One retailer asked this question: Is there an attained margin percentage that is considered a good goal for garden centers and their various product lines? Check out financial consultant Steve Bailey's advice.

Read More
Viola ‘Sorbet XP Coconut Swirl’ (PanAmerican Seed)

August 26, 2015

19 Versatile Cool-Weather Annuals For Beds, Borders And…

Annuals can be versatile not just in their suitability for cool conditions, but in their adaptable use in beds, borders and containers. Here are breeders' recommendations on their top new selections.

Read More
Holly Wilson Wilson’s Garden Center

August 25, 2015

How To Make Your Newsletter More Interesting [Solve My …

A retailer recently asked how to come up with fresh ideas for your store’s eNewsletter, so that it does not become redundant. Here's some great advice the retailer received.

Read More
Farwest Nursery Tour

August 25, 2015

Farwest Show Will Include A Retail-Focused Idea Sharing…

The 2015 Farwest Show, taking place this week in Portland, Ore., will include an Idea Center For Retailers, a comprehensive learning experience focused on garden retail. Located on the main show floor, garden center owners and employees can participate in many sessions as industry experts share advice and how-to information.

Read More

August 24, 2015

Let Us Know About Your Greatest New Idea!

October is "Steal This Idea" month at Today's Garden Center. We're looking for the latest, greatest and most successful new ideas that you've incorporated at your store and are willing to share with your industry peers.

Read More

August 24, 2015

PANTS Show In Philadelphia Canceled For 2015

The Pennsylvania Landscape & Nursery Association (PNLA) was informed by the PANTS Show producer that this year’s show, planned for early November, has been canceled. PNLA is reviewing its options for the future.

Read More

August 24, 2015

Mark Your Calendar For These Gift Shows

Want to enhance your gift department? Here's a look at some of the major gift shows taking place later this year and early next year.

Read More
Ingenico EMV

August 24, 2015

Small Retailers May Face Big Challenges In Complying Wi…

The National Retail Federation’s J. Craig Shearman says it may take a couple years for credit cards with EMV chips to become the norm, but retailers should still begin preparing, or face increased liability.

Read More
Helleborus ‘Winter Jewels Painted Doubles’ (Terra Nova Nurseries) FEATURED IMAGE

August 21, 2015

12 Cold-Hardy Perennials For 2016 [Slideshow]

Your customers are likely looking for plants that can withstand cold temperatures. Here's a look at breeders' suggestions for some of their favorite cool-weather perennials.

Read More
USA flowers

August 18, 2015

Gift Shows Are Focusing On Local Products

Hoping to change the buying experience for attendees, gift show organizers are adapting through technology and a focus on locally produced items.

Read More

August 18, 2015

6 Super Ideas From Product Express

Take a look at some innovative new products that will add a spark to your business!

Read More
IGC East Martha Stewart

August 18, 2015

Eight Insights From Martha Stewart’s Keynote Pres…

Martha Stewart's Q&A presentation with Jeff Morey at IGC East in early August yielded some revealing information about her branding, and how the independent garden center industry can stay relevant in a changing market.

Read More
Geary-Michael

August 18, 2015

Michael Geary Is Leaving AmericanHort

AmericanHort president and CEO Michael Geary announced last Wednesday that he will be leaving his position at the end of September to serve as CEO of the Society for Marketing Professional Services. “I am writing to share with you that on October 8 I will begin a new professional chapter as CEO of the Society for Marketing Professional Services, an organization dedicated to creating business opportunities in the architecture, engineering and construction industries,” Geary said in an email. His last day with AmericanHort will be Sept. 30, 2015. “As some of you know, I grew up connected to the horticulture industry so this was not an easy decision for me,” he said. “I have loved working with our organizations and our talented members, staff and partners. However, my choice to return full time to Washington, D.C. will allow me to be closer to my family and aging parents and to re-engage with another industry […]

Read More
Mother and Daughter gardening

August 17, 2015

5 Things You Need To Know About Young Plant Consumers […

Younger garden consumers think it’s important for children to learn how to grow plants, even though they themselves see gardening as a time-consuming and expensive hobby, our latest research shows. This insight was just one of many unearthed by Today’s Garden Center’s 10% Project as it seeks ways to increase consumer interest in plants and local garden centers. We conducted three focus groups made up of consumers under 50 years old during the late winter this year. These focus groups took place over three days. The first focus group was made up of 18-29 year olds, the second of 30-49 year olds and the third of parents with children between 2 and 12. Our next steps are to develop marketing campaigns based on issues our research revealed, then work with garden centers to use the marketing during the spring of 2016 and measure the results. You may recall Today’s Garden […]

Read More

August 17, 2015

What Consumers Under 50 Have To Say About Plants, Garde…

This report serves as a first installment in the findings from the online focus groups as the first portion of our project with Flowers Canada entitled, “Keeping the Interest in Gardening Alive!” This is the first step in the project. Subsequent steps are to (b) identify marketing campaigns, (c) develop campaigns with Ontario garden retailers for spring 2016, (d) measure impacts of those campaigns in summer 2016, and (e) craft a marketing handbook with the information collected from the project by the end of summer 2016. Data Collection In order to ascertain the thoughts, attitudes, and perceptions of three age groups of Ontario residents, we worked with GutCheck (http://www.gutcheckit.com/) to conduct three separate focus groups. The groups were Gen Y (ages 18-29), Gen X (ages 30-49) and parents of children ages 2-12. The first one held was with parents (both fathers and mothers) of children ages 2-12 which took 5 […]

Read More
Ingenico EMV

August 17, 2015

Study Shows Small Businesses Largely Unprepared For EMV

With the October 1 EMV liability shift looming, a recent survey indicated that more than half of all small businesses will not be ready.

Read More
Frank Pesche, Pesche's Garden Center

August 14, 2015

Frank Pesche of Pesche’s Flower and Garden Center Dies …

Pesche, a long-time owner of the Des Plaines, Ill. garden center, helped expand the company beyond its roots as a retail florist.

Read More